Coming up with a systematic way to paraphrase sentences involving some wacky new term W in biology, sociology, psychology, or art criticism, into sentences that are just a logical product of claims about sets, mereological sums of other more commonplace objects, and preserves all our intuitive reasoning about W, is useful in three ways.

a) New Applications for Old Knowledge: Getting a method of paraphrase lets us bring our logical/set theoretic/substantive knowledge about the terms used in the analysis to bear on the new term in question. If the facts about the Ws parallel the facts about sets of such and such kind, set theory may have interesting implications for facts about the Ws.

b) Avoiding Adding Terms Which are "Incoherent" or "Have False Presuppositions": Getting a method of paraphrase may let us prove the consistency and conservativity of reasoning about the wacky new entities. For example if you analyze 'x is bachelor' as 'x is unmarried & x is a man', and then only accept informal reasoning about bachelors that can be reconstructed using this analysis, then it is clear that adding the term 'bachelor' and doing this informal reasoning will not allow you to derive contradiction, or any other new consequences. So, adding informal reasoning about bachelors will do no harm. Here the proof theory (any proof of P which uses the term "bachelor" could be turned into one that doesn't) is so obvious that it's easy not to notice. But the mathematical issues involved in showing consistency and/or conservativity of adopting some term (together with analytic feeling reasoning that goes with that term) can become more interesting when conceptual analysis only provides an *implicit* or recursive definition of the term.

This is valuable, to the extent that you are worried a purported new concept may be 'incoherent' (in the sense that intuitive, analytic feeling reasoning about it literally lets you prove contradiction) or may have bad 'presuppositions' (in the sense that that intuitive, analytic feeling, reasoning using the term allows one to derive new propositions not using that term, which are false)

c) Teaching: Obviously getting a method for paraphrase sentences involving new terminology in terms of old terminology provides a way of teaching the new terminology to people who already understand the old terminology.

Note that none of these purposes require that conceptual analyses be unique. Different analyses of claims about, say, the imaginary numbers, in terms of set theory can each serve this purpose equally well. Nor do these uses for conceptual analysis require that one make any claim about the metaphysical status of the objects in question. It's useful to know you can reconstruct all intuitively acceptable reasoning about the imaginary numbers in terms of intuitively acceptable reasoning about sets, even if you don't want to claim that the imaginary numbers ARE sets or anything like that. Nor, lastly, do they require that the analyses have some kind of psychological reality - that when you are thinking about imaginary numbers you are really somehow implicitly (subconsciously?) considering one or the other paraphrase in terms of sets.

[Hidden agenda: Even if it turns out that Occam's razor doesn't apply to positing special sciences objects like livers, species, trade deficits and languages, so there's no need to look for paraphrases which would allow us to *deny* that such "extra" objects exist, finding Quinean-style parapharases will still be illuminating and useful for other reasons. So we philosophers won't be talking ourselves out of a job :). Also, to the extent that you feel like something substantial is going on when one looks for Quinean methods of paraphrase, this may be because these paraphrases illuminate the structure of our intuitive reasoning about Ws, and let us relate the W facts to facts about objects we understand better - not because there is a serious question about whether the Ws really exist.]

婚姻對男人來說是賭他的自由，對女人而言卻是賭她的幸福。......................................................

ReplyDeletekk視訊內衣秀 免費情色av影片 情色小魔女自拍 免費情色影片無碼 qq美美色網免費看 ut辣妹哈啦視訊聊天室 34c美女寶貝視訊 ez聊天網 avdvd成人影城 aa台辣妹有約 34c玩美女人百分百貼影片區 一葉情貼圖片區 383 天下貼圖情趣 商品 一對多視訊大學生情人 gogo2sex視訊妹 線上免費視訊聊天 yam天空辣妹影音 視訊交友etude 比基尼辣妹 kk272視訊 A片-sex520 影音聊天室fm358 sex520 net視訊美女 080視訊聊天室how2 85st免費影片觀看 小弟弟成人娛樂網 辣妹視訊聊天室 90691 免費熟女人影片 g8mm 視訊小愛 比基尼美女的奶,玩美女人影音秀 383影音城a 情色視訊,貓貓論壇 啦咧華人視訊交友聊天室 38ga成人 辣妹有約溫泉 微風愛情館論壇aio 我愛78論壇影片 飯島愛免費影片 辣手美眉甜心寶貝直播貼片 免費a片觀看 視訊交友loveliness av影片下載 avhigh免費影片 限制性影片 hi5 tv 免費聊天情人fm358 a383girl影音城 亞洲視訊34c甜心寶貝直播貼片 免費聊天mmshow 南台灣視訊網愛聊天室

ReplyDelete性愛淫蕩淫慾淫亂淫婦淫妹淫叫淫水淫女情慾情色做愛限制級波霸口交18禁貼圖寫真視訊援交露點爆乳潮吹裸體裸照裸女愛愛無碼尋夢視訊聊天a漫a片a圖一夜情

ReplyDeleteA stitch in time saves nine...................................................

ReplyDeleteUT網際空間 UT網際空間 漂亮寶貝 人妖系列 交換夫妻 亞亞成人 亞洲免費 丹麥美女 中文搜色 清涼寫真 一業情貼 一夜留言 一葉晴貼 浣腸調教 泳裝美女 氣質美女 正妹麻將 歐美影片 歐美線上 檳榔西施 曖曖影片 日本寫真 日本女星 日本女郎 日本女生 日本同志 日本制服 撥霸美女 援助交易 接吻技巧 接吻影片 手槍美女 成人片觀 愛秀影音 想入非非 情人視訊 微風線上 影音聊天 影片交流 影片亞洲 廁所盜攝 已婚聊天 少年阿賓 小倉優子 小魔女拍 小說頻道 小說線上 寫真女星 娜美羅賓 女星寫真

ReplyDelete